It still seems incredible - that one crazed individual could slaughter 32 of his fellow students and teachers. All that disturbed individual had to do was to walk into a shop, sign a piece of paper, and re-emerge with a semi-automatic 9 mm Glock. Once he had laid his hands on a second similar weapon, and hundreds of rounds of ammunition, some of which was hollow-headed - designed to kill- he had become a veritable killing machine.
Myself and some others used Toby Harnden's blogs to state one or two home-truths on America's so-called "gun culture" - or as others less flatteringly put it, "gun fetish". But I don't think any of us were prepared for the incendiary response which that elicted from the Stateside regulars who post comments there.
Given the kind of abuse that's been coming the last day or two, notably from "Maddie", and especially Mary Fernandez (Captain), I felt obliged to submit the following to the thread this morning, under the title : "Over the top, and over here".
Here's a link to a blog in the Washington Post , written by E.J.Dionne Jr.
In the short extract that follows, the author makes clear his exasperation, shared by many others in a long, long comments section.
"No one pretends that smarter gun laws would prevent all violence. But it's a disgrace that we can't try to learn from tragedies such as this week's Virginia Tech massacre and figure out whether better laws might at least modestly reduce the likelihood of such horrific events happening again.
Our country is a laughing stock on the rest of the planet because of our devotion to unlimited gun rights. "
I have still to read the entire thread, but some things are clear. One is the polarisation of opinion on the subject of guns. The other is the sense of weary acceptance that nothing will done to control the easy-availability of guns, given the NRA's throttle-hold on US politics. One writer goes so far as to suggest that it was Gore's position on gun control that lost him the election.
However, I do not see anyone being subjected to the kind of derisive put-downs we have seen from Maddie, far less the hysterical rants from Mary F. Either Americans are more moderate with their comments, or the Post's moderators are less tolerant of abusive comment, or possibly both.
Isn't it strange that the two Ms conduct themselves in this fashion on a UK-based blog ? Why do they post here, rather than the Washington Post, or comparable US newspapers ? Is it because they know they can indulge themselves here in hissy fits that would not be tolerated in their own country ?
Methinks that M&M have been taking some huge liberties. Am I alone in thinking this ? Does anyone else agree ?
Update Friday 10:55
I have just realised that an earlier submission to the same thread, sent last night, has not appeared. Maybe it's been censored, or perhaps it is being held back for legal checks ( since it mentions the Phil Spector trial, but is careful to refer to his "alleged" toting of guns ). Irrespective, here it is:
"I find myself asking why Maddie et al bother with blogs from such a piddling little country as ours.
What do they say to their friends or colleagues, one wonders, who find them forever at their laptops logged on to this site ? That they "like to get the UK perspective on US and world affairs" ? Maybe they do, or did, until, that is, it begins to differ from what they want to hear.
When affronted by our expressions of honest opinion, that's the signal for Maddie et al to go into public address mode, trying to silence us with their megadecibel blasts of invective.
Maybe they can't stomach the views that are expressed this side of the pond, views that are not constrained by the shibboleths they acquire from infancy through your parents, churches, schools etc. Our views are ones that make sense to a fairly typical medium-sized nation, living cheek by jowl with dozens of similar sized nations as distinct from a geographically somewhat isolated hulking continental superpower.
Given the geopolitical differences it is hardly surprising that our world-views should differ. We also condemn the absurdly high level of gun-related crime that we hear about almost every day now, whether it's Virginia Tech, or a NASA employee shooting dead a colleague whom he blamed for a bad job review, or a record producer alleged to routinely threaten women with guns for not succumbing to his cleverly disguised charms.
If you don't like the views expressed here, Maddie, there's a simple solution. I'm sure I don't need to tell an intelligent woman like yourself what that is.
So why carry on punishing yourself in this fashion? Do you think America will be weakened by the likes of me being left unchallenged to condemn America for its foreign policy or way of life from a distance of some 3,500 miles ? I feel hugely flattered if you do.
I'm told the Washington Post does good blogs. One wonders how its locally-based bloggers would react if one or more Brits took up residence, routinely flaming them for saying uncomplimentary things about the UK or its European neighbours?"
Comments welcome (by email only): sciencebod01@aol.com
Friday, April 27, 2007
Beware defenders of America's gun culture
Posted by
sciencebod
at
8:53 am
Labels: M.Fernandez, Maddie, Toby Harnden, US gun culture, Virginia tech massacre
Monday, April 16, 2007
Compendium of crap arguments used by the gun lobby
The death toll in the Virginia massacre now stands at 32. Even if it stayed at this figure, it ranks as the worst of a long and sickening series of such incidents.
The UK too has had its deranged killers turning guns on ordinary men, women and even tiny children - Hungerford and Dunblane are the horrors that spring to mind. The response to these, especially Dunblane, was such abject horror that the UK government under John Major introduced some of the world's most stringent gun control legislation. That does not make a repetition impossible, but probably far less likely: mercifully there has been no further massacres, even if illegally-held hand guns proliferate in inner cities, but that is a different kind of crime, ie the targeted killings of individuals rather than indiscriminate slaughter. That does not make it any less reprehensible - it's still the taking of life- but there's a greater horror to being gunned down by a complete stranger than by someone whom one is deemed to have crossed in the past, especially if in the pursuit of crime (often drugs-related).
This is what I have previously called a 'piton post'. This is the first purchase on a difficult subject. I posted the following earlier this evening to the Telegraph's "Your View" which poses the question "Why are there so many shootings in America ? "
"We've been here before, and sadly we'll be here again. Why ? Because Americans are too self-indulgent to take on board what is obvious to the rest of the world - namely that weapons of "self-defence" become the means for revenge and mass execution in the wrong hands.
Now where will it happens next time, one wonders ? Maybe in the States of those congressmen and senators who consistently vote against gun control legislation ?"
Already the weasel words have appeared on this thread, the dissembling, the attempts to shift blame. Tomorrow, I will pull these comments out the thread, and attempt a sane and rational reply to this sickening propaganda - much of which I suspect to be orchestrated.
Let's just start with that old chesnut.
"It's not the gun that kills. It's the person who fires it".
Incorrect. It's the gun that kills. That's why the gun is called a "weapon". Place that weapon in the hands of a deranged individual and it becomes what is called " a lethal weapon". All that is required of the user is to load, point and fire. Do that repeatedly with other human beings in the line of fire, and you have what is known as a "massacre". It's hardly rocket science, is it ?
"When you outlaw guns, only the outlaws will have guns"
Following Dunblane, the UK outlawed most guns, but did something very smart and unexpected. It allowed the police and armed forces to keep their weapons. This dispensation was granted because the police and armed forces are what are known as "the forces of law and order". Now who else but us clever Brits would have thought of doing that ? We're kind of funny like that, restricting lethal weapons to individuals who are trained and disciplined, wear a uniform, undergo regular medical tests etc etc.
It's not just guns that kill. Are you going to ban knives and baseball bats as well ?
If someone goes berserk in a public place wielding a knife or baseball bat, I like to think I would have a go. I'd grab whatever was available - a chair say- and use it defensively to get in close, and then offensively, to disable the nutter. But if he was using a firearm, I'd do the same as everyone else - armed police included - which is to hit the deck and try to stay out of the line of fire, on the assumption, correct or otherwise, that a bullet can be lethal at 100 yards or more.
They banned guns in the UK, and what happened ? - shootings increased ! Your gun control had the opposite effect to the one intended.
I wish I had £5 for every time I've seen that bit of puerile nonsense. The UK's draconian gun control legislation was a response to Dunblane, Hungerford and other multiple shootings that were carried out with weapons legally owned. Their owners were people who had previously been considered to be mentally sound, but who suddenly flipped, and then turned themselves into killing machines. There is only one rational response to that, which is to make it harder for ordinary citizens to own guns. That does not prevent the criminal fraternity, or drug cartels, or inner city gangs from obtaining illegal weapons. But they tend to be used mainly for internecine warfare, for criminal holdups etc which, although a blot on civilized society, do not have the same ability to shock as the kind of revolting mass slaughter we saw yesterday.
Even the summary "execution" of one bunch of hoods by another, as in the St.Valentine's Day Massacre, induces a strong sense of revulsion. Substitute bright young university students, full of hopes and dreams for the future, for those Chicago gangsters and one's sense of indignation and outrage goes offscale.
We bare (sic) the right for the simple reason that if for any reason a radical faction were to gain control of this great nation, the U.S., then the populace would have the duty to rise up and resist.
Oh yes ? And what about the Armed Forces ? Whose side are they on when you descend on the White House to turf out the bunch you so despise ? Better make sure they are on yours. But if they, then your services are not required, and you can put your Smith and Wesson back under your pillow, and continue lying awake, waiting for sounds in the back yard.
But here's another question to ponder: how come other counties manage to rid themselves of police states, totalitarian regimes and oddball dictators etc without their waiters, filling station attendants, shopworkers etc having to become instant Rambos for the duration ? Are you not aware of the various revolutions that have occurred around the world in recent years, with few if any shots being fired, that have succeeded either by peaceful means - public protests, general strikes, or by the military staging a quick clinical coup, and installing a provisional government ?
Who's to say that a ragtag assortment of gun-toting vigilantes are not lying in wait right now, at various secret locations dotted throughout the Appalachians, seeking any pretext to take over, and who once installed at the White House (in their dreams) , would announce that since they represent the true will of the people, they are there to stay.
Update: Tuesday 11:45 Toby Harnden has just posted to his Telly blog on this topic. Here's my tuppenceworth, under the title "Taking aim at the gun lobby" which appeared within seconds of submitting:
"I put up a new post on my blog yesterday under the indelicate title: "Compendium of crap arguments used by the gun lobby". So far, I've taken just 4 of the intelligence-insulting debating points that get trotted out after each of these massacres, and tried to give them short shrift. But if the comments appearing on "Your View" (currently standing at 182) are anything to go by, several more will need addressing before the day is out.
One suspects that America's love affair with guns is finally beginning to wane, given the all-too-prevalent philosophy of "Love thy neighbor, until he gets on your nerves, in which case you go downtown, buy a gun, shoot the b*stard - and all the other neighbors too while you're about it".
Second contribution to the Harnden thread:
Title: Diversions from the point at issue
Why this constant attempt to muddy the waters, by reference to explosives or knives?
Making bombs requires knowledge, commitment, taking risks with one's own life. As such it is the weapon of the terrorist, which seems an apt desciption of Timothy McVeigh. He had a political grudge.
But Hungerford, Dunblane, Columbine and now Virginia were the work of people whose grudge was against neighbours, fellow students etc and for whom the possession of weapons made it absurdly easy for them to go on their killing sprees.
There was an instance of someone going berserk with a machete at a Wolverhampton school, in which the teacher and several children were grievously wounded. But mercifully no one died, and the assailant was finally disarmed - not something one can readily do when firearms are involved.
The UK's stringent gun control legistation was a response to nutters intent on indiscriminate slaughter. It was never imagined that it would curb the activity of terrorists, gun-toting gang members, or the smash-and-grab criminal fraternity. Attempts by the gun lobby to claim that increases in those fringe activities involving illegally owned weapons, ones that don't generally involve multiple killings, are proof that gun control in the UK has failed, are an attempt to distract from the success of the legislation: so far there have been no further Dunblane/Virginia type massacres on UK soil.
I think Robert Fraser has me confused with someone else. I am not a Marxist, nor am I wildly enthusiastic about the EU (but feel that if it didn't exist, something similar would have to be invented).
I lived and worked in the USA for 2 years.The Kent State campus killings occurred while I was there - but that was the so-called disciplined National Guard doing the shooting. If that's how the forces of law and order behave when armed, is it any wonder that private citizens think so little about arming themselves to the teeth, and turning themselves into killing machines ?
Colin Berry at 17 Apr 2007 11:51
Third contribution to Harnden thread
Title: Save the tears for later
Toby, in his post, hinted at the dilemma one faces when each new shooting spree occurs: how long do we restrict ourselves to expressions of grief before cutting to the chase ? Don Hughes is adamant that talk of the causes and remedies is premature: we should wear our black armbands for a week before addressing the underlying issues.
Well, you can count me out, not through any disrespect for the dead, or to those who are suddenly bereaved (my heart goes out to them) but out of respect for the bereaved-to-be.
Because while otherwise sane and rational people come to this and other sites, saying that guns, and their free availability, are here to stay in US society, and that obscenities like Virginia are the price one pays for Americans' atavistic need to possess a firearm, then future bloodbaths such as occurred yesterday are assured.
Meanwhile, we Brits and Europeans are forced to watch these frightful images on our screens with monotonous regulariity, to empathise with people who have seen their sons and daughters lives snuffed out in an instant, and when we come to our home grown blogs such as this to express our indignation and outrage, what happens ? Stateside apologists for the blood-soaked status quo insult our intelligence by trotting out the same old drivel, the same recycled evasive or mudslinging claptrap, probably cadged from some dog-eared NRA manual that appeared in the mailbox at the time of the last elections for Congress or Senate, and has been sitting on the mantelpiece ever since, to be dusted off on occasions such as this.
I would like to express my deep respect for all future victims of US style massacres, perpetrated by disturbed individuals firing off indiscriminately with weapons easily purchased, and legally owned.
So next time there's a Virginia-style masssacre, I shall feel free to pick up this argument where we left off, with no decent period of mourning, and preface my remarks with this sentence, in quotation marks, dated 17th April 2007.
Anyone care to guess how long we wait for the next one, how many victims, and how many folk pop up on blogs with trite remarks like "Look, it's not the gun that kills, bla bla bla .... ? ".
Fourth contribution to Harnden thread:
Title: An argument that cuts both ways
You had to go back to the 1920s to find your example of massacre-by-dynamite, Karen. There would presumably have been more recent cases if dynamite were available, over the counter, the way that your guns are.
Ipso facto, restrict the sale of guns, as you do dynamite, and the Karens of the 22nd century might have to go back through the archives to 2007 to find when the last mass execution by shop-bought firearms took place.
Update: Wed 18th April, 01:30 The following has just been submitted to Toby Harnden's blog, but will probably not appear until tomorrow morning. It's a response to that vocal all-female US lobby that cruises the Telegraph blogs in search of what it sees as anti-US sentiment. Woe betide anyone who attracts those beady eyes !
"Dear Arlene, Maddie, Mary F et al
Nothing would please me more than deal with all the many points you raise, some relevant, some flippant, but it would end up looking like a legal defence from someone charged with a public order offence (maybe that was the idea !) and be so long as to look somewhat self-indulgent. But how many are still reading this thread anyway, so that exercise is hardly worth the candle (look at the time of posting!)?
So I decided instead to stay constructive, and have just posted the following to the "Your View" thread, in the smug knowledge that the last submission sits at the top of the pile !!!
"There is one disturbing possibility that all Americans need to consider, namely that the real motive in all these shooting sprees was suicide.
Think about it: Hungerford, Dunblane, Columbine, Virginia: in all these tragic incidents, the perpetrators shot themselves BEFORE coming under fire from police marksmen. So who's to say that without the easy availability of hand guns in America (or in Britain until after Dunblane) the perpetrators would have been forced to despatch themselves by other means (overdoses, jumping in front of trains, off tall buildings etc) that do not generally injure others.
But by making available to disturbed people a quick clinical means of suicide, it's hardly surprising that a small proportion decide to precede the act of self-destruction with one for which the gun was actually designed, namely shooting other people.
Gun owners will naturally protest that their weapons are intended for self-defence, not intentional homicide, but the subtlety of that distinction may be lost on a certain type who feels driven to suicide, and is more angry than sad.
Maybe a certain type of suicidee sees the gun as a tool for making society pay a price for bringing them to the point where suicide seems the only escape from their problems of adjustment.
If this analysis is correct, then Columbines and Virginias are inevitable for as long as guns are easily available, especially as each horror tends to spawn copycat versions.
America and other nations with lax gun control are playing a deadly game of Russian roulette with their schoolchildren, students, and other citizens."
Update: Wednesday 09:20: Toby Harnden has a new post ("In the dorm room of a mass murderer"), in which he asks why the warning signs were not spotted and acted upon, given that student's strange behaviour. This has just been sent off:
"There are 300 million people in the US, which means 300 million unique personalities, all trying to make sense of the modern world.
Among them sadly will be those who have given up hope of understanding the world around them, who are contemplating suicide, and are casting around for a means of ending it all.
America's lax gun laws mean they can go out and purchase, with absurd ease, a highly efficient means of self-dispatch - a firearm.
But if they feel so inclined they can also use it take their revenge on a society which they hold responsible for their feeling so worthless.
So if you are looking for warning signs of an imminent massacre, Toby, I would have thought the sight of a college student going into a gunshop and splashing out some $600 dollars would be a reasonable start. What possible use would a student have for a semi-automatic pistol ? It's not as if he was a homeowner, wanting protection for himself or family against intruders.
Why were the university authorities not notified ? Perhaps Americans are more concerned about the human rights of gun owners than they are of citizens who choose not to bear arms - and who have unwisely, perhaps, placed their trust in a flawed system."
Update Wednesday 12:00 midday
Yesterday I signalled that I had said everything I wanted to say on Toby's original Virginia massacre post ( now off the blogroll, and only accessible in his personal folder). However, a somewhat detached, dare one say smug, late posting from "Martin" (surely not the same one I met at the Telly blogger's evening ?) provoked me to respond as follows:
Title: Sickening inevitability
"So Michael's risk of being randomly killed goes from 0.00000000001% to 0.00000000002%.
He seems not to care that the rest of us experience nausea when switching on our TV to watch the world news.
Meanwhile his fellow Americans, like the ones who post to this site, have the cheek to call us hard-nosed and hard-hearted for failing to join in on their post-Diana displays of heart-on-sleeve grieving.
Whereas Diana's death was almost certainly an accident (whatever Dodi's father might think) the 32 deaths in Virginia were entirely forseeable, thanks to America's lax gun laws. It's only a matter of time before we switch on our sets and go through the whole sickening spectacle again of a society playing Russian roulette with its children."
To be continued later today. Comments invited by email: sciencebod01@aol.com
Tuesday, April 10, 2007
Can blogging be made less abrasive ?

Updated Wed 11th at 12:30
"Bloggers urged to help clean up the web" is the title of an article by Toby Harnden and Sally Peck in today's Telly.
I had spotted this item in the Guardian this morning, and quickly resolved to make it the subject of the next post. Come 10 am I was halfway through writing it. But it all became too depressing for words, arguing for a few ground rules. Why ? Because I could hear the howls of protest. Who needs censorship ! Protect our freedom of speech ! The blog is a free spirit, not bound by the constraints of the printed page ! Away with you, Stalin/Hitler/ Attila the Hun (delete as appropriate).
It's some high-profile bloggers in the States who are pushing for a code of conduct, backed up by an easily recognized "kite"symbol that signals you have entered a zone of civility, policed by a blogmeister who has signed up to the scheme. Beyond that, it all got very technical and wordy, and I was frankly not inclined to take in all the detail. But rescue was at hand in the form of a "wiki", which invited one to contribute one's own ideas, which go into the melting point along with everyone elses. Well, that sounded like the soft option, so here's what I quickly bashed off to "Blogging Wikia" , sending a copy, natch, to the Comments under Toby's article.
Toby's really going to have to slow down. This shadowing of Telly blogs is getting to be hard work when he's around !
"I suspect that attempts to simulate an MSM level of moderation/censorship in personal blogs are doomed to failure. Most folk feel the disadvantages outweigh the advantages, and are prepared to tolerate a bit of hassle and occasional victimisation. It's sad but true.
Being myself the victim of chronic low-level harassment, verging occasionally on stalking behaviour, I've tried to read the mind of the perpetrator, and to think how posting might be made a little more difficult for that individual.
I know that I myself from time to time take a dislike to certain bloggers who post remarks that are predictable and banal, and feel tempted to get in with an instant riposte. But that's hardly grown up, is it, to become a kind of bull at whom someone waves a red flag, and off one goes at full gallop ?
Here's my remedy: there should be an understanding that all comments added to a new blog post must be comprehensible to someone visiting the blog for the first time. There must be no obscure references, in-jokes, wind-ups etc that would require the visitor to go searching back through the archives to find out what it was all about. Put more simply, one must not bring baggage to a new blog posting.
But what of the situation in which a fellow blogger has been banging on incessantly about a particular obsession, and is getting everybody's back up. In other words, "single-issue man/woman". Simple: if you want to raise it as an issue, then do so directly. Summarise, in a few well-chosen words, the source of irritation, rather than engage in sniping. That way the newcomers are quickly apprised of the problem, and can offer an opinion, thus opening up the perceived problem for general discussion."
Summary:Never bring baggage to a new blog posting. If it's your blog, prevent others from doing so.
In a few words, clamp down hard on "carry-over" of unresolved disputes.
Update: Wednesday 11th, 09:30 There's a must-read on this topic by Jonathan Freedland in today's Guardian with its reference to "point-scoring males" (aka survival of the loudest)
See also Shane Richmond's latest blog post ("Let the Internet look after itself") which appeared yesterday. He makes the interesting point that blogs can be self-regulating, to the extent that people will vote with their feet if a clique of boorish individuals monopolize a particular site. He chose not to illustrate with an example that springs readily to mind, which is perhaps understandable, but a pity all the same.
Oops: I could be accused of breaking my own rule there - dropping heavy hints that leave newcomers wondering who is being got at. So let's not mince our words. The blog to which I refer is Colin Randall's "Salut!". It gets plenty of hits each day, probably 4 times as many as this one, but there are long periods when it attracts few if any comments. Yet look at Colin Randall's
recent appearance on the Guardian's "Comment is Free". That attracts dozens of lively comments, so one cannot argue that Colin's prose has lost its charm - far from it.
There is a simple reason, or rather two, why people read Salut!, but decline to leave comments. They are called "Bill Taylor" and "Richard of Orléans". They fit Freedland's description of "point-scoring males" to a tee, although I could add a few extra tags myself.
One of them - the journalist- can write well, and has a good line in wit, but only when he has cleared the blog of all perceived rivals, and is then free to hold court.
I'm not saying anything I have not said already. Late last year I advised the resident rottweilers to take a three month holiday from Colin Randall's blog, by way of letting in some new blood in the Comments section . Advice ignored - and the result is plain for all to see.
Moving on, I guess it's everybody's duty to be on the lookout for humbug, and be prepared to become whistleblowers when they find it. Here was my good turn to the blogosphere yesterday re maintaining a respect for truth and transparency: it was sent as a second contribution to the Harnden/Peck thread referred to above:
"On my blog I have the option of publishing or rejecting any comment that visitors post. I do not publish objectionable comments. - No problem... (o:"
Posted by Margarete on April 10, 2007 1:32 PM
I have just visited Margarete's blog. There is not a single comment attached to her last 36 posts no less (that's where I stopped scrolling down). In fact it's not a blog at all - it's a shopwindow for her theory that obesity is caused by excessive salt consumption, and that what we thought was fat is actually just water(!). I've posted a negative comment, but it "will not appear until approved by the author ". One is not holding one's breath ...... Posted by Colin Berry on April 10, 2007 6:53 PM
No doubt she would accuse me of hypocrisy if making a cursory visit to Dreams and Daemons. But just a reminder: I have had most reluctantly to close down the separate Comments section due to harassment by a pair of ill-disposed individuals ("point-scoring males"). The option of deleting abusive comment is not workable if said individuals then leave comments on other blogs to the effect that I am authoritarian, an enemy of free speech blah blah blah. Thanks to those of you who have used the email facility.
Update Wed 12:30 pm. I have just submitted the following to the comments facility underneath Shane Richmond's article:
Fears about curbing free speech are a red-herring, one that distracts from the real issue, but which gets referred to only once in the above article.
The real issue is one of harassment, which sometimes leads by degrees to stalking behaviour. Harassment is at best tedious, but in the example quoted, is decidedly sinister.
Targetting and harassment of fellow bloggers is, I believe, often a manifestation of obsessive-compulsive behaviour. As such, it's unhealthy, and ought to be recognized and addressed.
I share peoples' concerns for the sanctity of free speech. But if each time I stepped inside my local, the same guy jumped out, grabbed me by the lapels, berated me for being personally complicit in some subject dear to his heart, let's say the Slave Trade, and then began calling me all the names under the sun, I would expect the publican to step in on my behalf. That's because the haranguer is abusing someone else's hospitality, ie it's not his pub.
And it's the pub's trade that stands to suffer if allowed to go unchecked.
Update 16:15 No comments have appeared (the above one having been found wanting, it would appear !)
Update 15:50 Resubmitted the rejected piece to Shane Richmond's blog on the same topic, prefaced with the following preamble :
Title: Maybe the ground's less stony here ?
Comments were invited at the end of Shane Richmond's article in the main body of the paper, but so far, none has appeared, including this one that I made earlier. Maybe the blog moderators are a little less pernickety, so here's a copy:
And guess what ? It appeared almost immediately !
Update 18:50 : Have just added the following to the end of Colin Randall's blog on the Guardian's Comment is Free:
"Great bunch of comments, everybody. Have you considered posting to Colin Randall's Salut! blog ? Infusion of new blood urgently needed there in the Comments section!"
http://colinrandallfrance.blogspot.com/
Comments invited: emails to sciencebod01@aol.com
Posted by
sciencebod
at
9:15 pm
Labels: Bill Taylor, blogging code of conduct, blogging wikia, Colin Randall, Margarete's blog, Richard of Orléans, Sally Peck, Salut, Toby Harnden
Thursday, January 11, 2007
Telegraph pulls Toby Harnden blog

ed April 11th 2007 : scroll down to brown font to read the comments placed on Toby Harnden's "Hoodgate" blog post
Update:Sunday 14 Jan Dreams and Daemons has been described by Suw Charman on her Corante site as the blog "the Telegraph does not want you to read". Her remit for that highly-ranked blog of hers: "Picking out the patterns from the chaos that is the blogosphere" .
ed. Oops. One has overlooked Corante's co-author, Kevin Anderson, featured lower down the home page, who is described as the Guardian's blog editor. Thought I to ought mention that, since I had already decided to do a "Be nice to the Guardian week" (having dipped a toe in its blogging waters recently, and been pleasantly surprised) .
But before readers assume that I have been frozen out of a favourite (if currently problematical) haunt, see Shane Richmond's most recent post to his Telegraph blog. There you will find a friendly difference of opinion between the two of us on the matter of IT jargon, with welcome reinforcement coming from none other than Sarah Hague. The matter of creeping jargon-blight had been raised by me earlier with Ceri Radford, the Telly's literary aficionado whose day job is acting as Chief Moderator on readers' comments. Poor kid.
Re jargon, congratulations are in order for Blogger, our host, for this message that one sees when logging on:
"We're already moving some lucky people, but you can cut the line and switch now".
Although clearly written by someone in California (please, can someone explain to this Brit what's meant by "cut the line" ?) note that he or she was content to use the simple "moving".
Not so the geeks who supply the Telegraph's IT software, who currently inflict this monstrosity upon anyone who still tries accessing Toby Harnden's now-withdrawn Saddam execution blog post (see below):
"We have recently migrated some content over from an old blogging engine, so it's possible that we haven't migrated the item you were looking for."
Ouch !
Update: Saturday 13 Jan There's a must-see article in today's Guardian, entitled "Telegraph gets tough with bloggers" That's a reference to the Telegraph's own bloggers, needless to say.
Shane Richmond, the online News Editor, has been reading the riot act to his team of bloggers (some 38 at the last count), warning them against getting too matey with the likes of us, or revealing too much about journalistic "tricks of the trade". Now who did he have in mind, one wonders ? Toby, or not Toby ? That is the question.
Update: 19:50 London time. Hello. This will be the fourth or fifth time today that I have tried to update this report. Every attempt so far has been frustrated by Blogger's buggy software that throws up supposed faults in the html code when I try to publish (after, say, 20 minutes of editing or more), meaning I have to abort and lose the lot. So this is entered now as plain text, not formatting as bold, or italics, or coloured font, purely to see if this time it's accepted. Even as I type, text is inserting into previous sentences and paragraphs. Is this really the 21st century ? If so, bring back yesterday , and my Amstrad 1512 with its Edline text editor. Anyway, I shall stop here, now things are quietening down (traffic from OrganGrinder on the Guardian) with this simple addition, and see if it "sends" without suffering sensory overload or going into a big sulk. If it does, I'll return later with a backlog of updates.
Come back, Alan Sugar. All is forgiven (especially as I've just had to delete/paste your surname from the end of the sentence to its proper position). Is it just me, or is everything just ..... ? (just had to relocate that question mark as well...)
NB This blog post has now been reorganized to make it more user-friendly. Toby Harnden's comments now come first, followed by the first 35 or so comments, when I then stopped saving. These are followed by 4 of my own comments, sent after I had stopped saving everything that appeared.
For a complete transcript of the blog post, go to OrganGrinder (see Links in margin), which appeared the following day. In fact Handyblogman kindly gave "Dreams and Daemons" first refusal, which was politely declined, for fear of making this post unwieldy, although there were other considerations that need not bother us now.
************************************************************************************
Want to know what Toby Harnden said in his withdrawn blog, and some of the initial reader reaction ?
Start here, but it may be disjointed in parts, or repetitious, as a result of first recording events as they happened, and then ( hurriedly) re-organizing in logical time-sequence.
20:55 Thursday The graphic at the top of this post shows what was visible on our screens just 45 minutes ago. It was the opening of Toby Harnden's latest blog for the Daily Telegraph. It then suddenly disappeared, without any word of explanation, having accrued some 84 Comments, most of them irate. It would appear that the Telegraph has pulled it, perhaps on the advice of its lawyers, given the acrimony and accusations of impropriety and professional malpractice flying back and forth.
Here is Toby Harnden's now-withdrawn blog post :
"So there I was the other morning, checking my Inbox. Amongst the offers of cheap Viagra and financial deals with dodgy Nigerians nestled an email from a dear reader, offering a remark about my work. That's the thing about this brave new world. Want to say what you think? Post a comment below. Reach me direct? Click on that email address over there to the right. Feeling forward? Call me on my mobile. Hey, the number's out there. "An appalling s*** of a man", read the subject line of the message. A verdict on George W. Bush or Donald Rumsfeld? An epitaph for Saddam Hussein, or John Kerry's career? No, apparently this was a reference to me. "Harnden - you were a total c*** in the Royal Navy, and you continue to be one even today," the email went on - and I quote verbatim, apart from the asterisks, misspellings and all. "How on earth you ever were accepted by the Telegraph as an alleged 'journalist', the Lord only knows." "Your piece on Saddam Hussein's execution (full of inaccuracies and made-up background) had me and my colleagues chortling for hours. No wonder the foregn desk pulled the piece shortly after its appearance. "Why don't you take up window-cleaning or something more suited to your meague abilities? Sincerely, Ian Black". Well, thanks for that Ian. Jolly nice of you to be back in touch, though my memory of our purported previous meeting has sadly faded. Glad I was able to provide some mirth. You're right that writing about Saddam's hanging before it happened was not my finest hour. It was one of those tricky journalistic challenges when no matter how much you hedge and speculate, the reality will always mischievously diverge from the finely-turned piece one filed. Thankfully, my industrious on-line colleagues helped me out and history now records an updated version, though the doomed dictator remains forever hooded in the headline. Hey, ho. I Googled Ian using his email address and it appears he is a "Scotsman living in China". A couple of years back, he wanted us "all to know that the courage of the Canadian forces in WW2 will never be forgotten and always appreciated. Thank you and God Bless." Nice thought, Ian. For some writers, like Joel Stein, all this interaction can be a bit much. Not me. Really, some people have said much worse. As Colin Berry reports, there can be the odd snafu with comments - but please, stick at it. I even emailed Ian back. Strangely, he hasn't been in touch again. Maybe he thinks that feedback only works one way. Update: The situation with the Saddam hanging illustrated that "old media" difficulty of the fixed newspaper deadline and the complications of writing across time zones. It was 5am on the morning of Friday December 29th in Washington, 10am in UK and midday in Baghdad when it began to look like Saddam was going to hang imminently. By our deadline of 6pm London time (1pm Washington, 9pm Baghdad), we had to finalise the stories for a paper that many people would read after - possibly - Saddam had hanged. Or by then Saddam might have been given a stay of execution. Or he might have been just about to hang. Another possibility was he would have been hanged but no details at all would have been released. Clearly, whatever happened this was a huge story that everyone would want to know every detail of. Much of the interest would focus on on the ghoulish procedure for the hanging. The Iraqi authorities had already carried out dozens of these and there had been briefings from US and Iraqi officials on what would happen - he would be hooded, dressed in a boiler suit, probably hanged at Camp Cropper etc etc. One of the three pieces the foreign desk asked me to write was on how the hanging was likely to happen, based on the briefings and the previous hangings. That's what I wrote, making crystal clear that the piece was written before the hanging. Saddam hanged just before dawn in Baghdad on December 30th, the early hours in UK and the evening of the 29th in Washington. Of course, we now know from Saddam's YouTube moment that the hanging was a shambles, that almost every normal Iraqi practice was departed from and virtually every aspect of planned procedure was violated. And there was my before-the-event piece being read on the morning of Saturday December 30th in UK illustrating just how differently things had turned out. "
Posted by Toby Harnden at 09 Jan 07 08:49
Toby Harnden: biographical details: Toby Harnden has been The Daily Telegraph's United States Editor since October 2006. He lives in Washington DC with his wife Cheryl and their dog Finn, a native of Belfast. Toby was previously Chief Foreign Correspondent for The Sunday Telegraph. He first joined The Daily Telegraph in 1994 and has been its Ireland Correspondent, Washington Bureau Chief and Middle East Correspondent. He is the author of Bandit Country: The IRA & South Armagh (1999). An archive of his work is at http://www.tobyharnden.com/, and he can be contacted at toby.harnden@telegraph.co.uk.
ed: Here are the first 35 or so comments:
Ian Black's comment shown in red.
Well done!!
I totally agree with Mr Black's earthy comments about you!! I have, thankfully, never had the dubious pleasure of meeting you, but the pomposity displayed in your blog indicates that your head is, as the Australians are apt to say, clearly buried deeply up your arse.I, too, read the appalling story you filed (by your own admission) even before Saddam had been executed. I don't think many people (if any) would take your jottings seriously henceforth.
Dr Jane Devonport at 09 Jan 2007 09:53
Your neck on the block
Dear Mr Harnden: I am sitting on the train fron Tunbridge Wells heading for central London, idling away an hour or two until I reach my office.Ir would appear that your somewhat waspish, vindictive response to a reader has stirred up a veritable hornet's nest, one that has sent you springing into action on defensive mode grade one!!I did not see the report referred to by the readers above (although two fellow travellers say they did read it and they tell me they do remember it well because of its apparent shortcomings).Did you never hear the phrase "If you can't take a joke, don't join" during your National Service in the navy?When you get something wrong, as you apparently did, caution should be the order of the day.Wind your neck in Sunny Jim, and pray that the boss has had a good New Year or else the noose that sent yon Saddam to his doom may tighter round YOUR rubber neck.Metaphorically speaking, of course.
Gregory Kemp at 09 Jan 2007 10:52
I know how you feel Toby
As a published writer myself, I know full well that for every fan that writes to tell you they love your work, there are five unhinged idiots ready and waiting in the wings to make your life hell. The world is full of loonies with nothing better to do with their day than fire off idiotic comments to other people, such as "Dr Devenport" in the previous post. If she doesn't take your "jottings" seriously then why is she reading your work in the first place?Don't despair Toby. There are lots of people out there that enjoy reading your work. Don't let the lunatic minority ruin your day.
Thomas Bosch at 09 Jan 2007 11:05
Missing the point
Mr Bosch appears to miss the point. Your earlier respondents seem to have been complaining about the flagrant inaccuracy of your offerings. Is Bosch suggesting that he expects other Telegraph readers to accept any slipshod workmanship which might appear in your newspaper's columns too?
Enzo at 09 Jan 2007 11:30
Ref good journalism
I am a comparatively old hack, having been in the newspaper business for some 40 years. I do not recall having seen - ever - such a pitiful response as the one Toby Harden had the gall to publish on his blog today.Not only did he fail to justify his having filed a story riddled with half-truths and downright errors.He had the temerity to defend it by referring (in his reply to Mr Black)to the story thus, and I quote:"You're right that writing about Saddam's hanging before it happened was not my finest hour. It was one of those tricky journalistic challenges when no matter how much you hedge and speculate, the reality will always mischievously diverge from the finely-turned piece one filed".Tricky journalistic challenges? The only "tricky challenge" I ever learned as a cub reporter on the Dundee Courier was this one - GET IT RIGHT!!We don't want hedging and speculation in the stories we pay for when we buy out Daily Telegraph each morning.We were not ALL born yesterday, Mr Harnden, and you'd do well to remember that your audience is both wide and experienced and unwilling to tolerate poor work.As you say in truth - "not your finest hour".
Stuart Knight at 09 Jan 2007 11:59
Surprised
Mr Harnden - you seem to be earning yourself an unenviable reputation for below-par reporting since you arrived in the USA a few weeks ago.I was most surprised to see your admission today that you had apparently made up or otherwise manufactured the account of Saddam Hussein's execution which I read online on the day he died.
Carlos Riccardi at 09 Jan 2007 12:07
Saddam's death
I do not usually write to newspapers, but I have to say I was very disappointed to read your message referring to reader Ian Black.If what you write about his message to you is correct, then you ought to have kept that information to yourself.By publishing his comments on the blog (did he give you permission to do so) you have exposed yourself to ridicule.If he did indeed refer to you by these rude epithets, Mr Black may have been incautious.But the fact that your initial story on Saddam Hussein's hanging in Bagdhad was wrong in significant detail does you absolutely no credit.Like your correspondent Enzo, I do not understand what Mr Bosch was talking about.If I want to read fiction I will go to John Le Carre - and not to the news pagers of the London Daily Telegraph.Most sincerely, F. L. Nitzsche
Frans at 09 Jan 2007 12:17
Your blog
To: Toby Harnden From: Helmut JohannsonDear Sir - it brightened my morning to read the contents of your blog today.Did you really make up all that descriptive detail of the Iraqi dictator's last moments?I agree with Mr Nitzsche's comments about fiction a-la-John Le Carre and what we expect from Telegraph reporters in the field.Where did you learn your craft (if I may call it that?).Maybe you ought to go back to night school or spend more time with your dog and less in front of the computer screen.
Helmut Johansson at 09 Jan 2007 12:38
Ho Ho Ho
I rest my case, Harnden, and stand by everything I said (and which you quoted without permission - always a risky line of attack as you are now discovering to your cost).Happy New Year and bon voyage on your journey home from the USA, which should not be long in coming if there's any journalistic justice left.People in glass houses should never throw stones - something else you seem to have forgotten, if ever you learned it.
Ian Black at 09 Jan 2007 12:45
Your blog
I'd prefer a grovelling apology to your inadequate (and snide) justification for the story from which you are now attempting to distance yourself.I know little about journalism.But I do know that Saddam's execution had massive international interest.But the fact is that you broke every rule in the book by filing something riddled with holes without either checking its veracity or having it held back for confirmation.The fact that you are now trying to blame your foreign desk staff holds no water with me, old fruit.Did you not have the guts to tell them to wait until you had all the facts at your fingertips?
Arthur Leonard Port at 09 Jan 2007 13:01
Mr Ian Black
Dear Mr Toby Harnden - I would like to have the e-mail address of Mr Ian Black. I believe he is a very experienced British foreign correspondent now working in China, where I now live and study.I met him at a seminar on international relations in Beijing two years ago, but have lost his address.If this is the same gentleman, he is a Scotsman who has been visiting my country for over 30 years and who has an excellent reputation in the People's Republic of China.We read the Daily Telegraph on-line here very often, and like very much the work of Mr Richard Spencer.But I must say many of us are sorely ashamed of the fact that you wrote lies in at least one of your reports.Shame on you Mr Toby!!
Lin Bin at 09 Jan 2007 13:24
Grubby Grub Street
May I say how heartened I am to read the comments addressed to Toby Harnden in today's blogs.It has not gone un-noticed in our officers' mess here in Baghdad (I am a Special Forces officer and Grey Thompson is therefore not my real name) that your so-called Washington Editor lied in his work.But I speak for many of my colleagues of all ranks when I say that Harnden's admission justifies our total rejection of the claims of accuracy and impartiality in the reporting of many American and foreign journalists working in Iraq.
Colonel Grey Thompson at 09 Jan 2007 13:39
Also ashamed
Mr Harnden - I am also a student in China (Inner Mongolia) and I, too, am ashamed that you have written lies in a well-respected newspaper.We not always believe what we read in the People's Daily, but we have come to depend upon the foreign press for the truth.You have done much to disillusion us here.
Penny at 09 Jan 2007 13:47
Ian Black's comments
From: Martin Allison in HanoiI am delighted to see that many of your readers are hitting back at Toby Harnden for his totally unacceptable explanation.You asked for us to "make your day", and by golly I imagine you've had much more than you bargained for.As another of your correspondents said, we were not born yesterday and are both experienced AND discerning when it comes to judging what we read.How many other Brtish nationals made the same gaffe as Harnden, if any?
Martin Allison at 09 Jan 2007 13:56
Take heed
I am a journalism student currently travelling in Asia, and have just come across this man's blog.Mr Harnden would seem to have an awfully high opinion of himself, one that is wholly unjustified, in my humble opinion.He should take heed of what readers say about him.
Serena McKenzie at 09 Jan 2007 14:01
Doggy style
Talk about dog eating dog!! Nothing like the feathers of a bumptious journo being ruffled.Cool it, Harnden. You can dish it out but it seems you can' take it (criticism, that is).You're not in the navy now, you know!!
Alastair Wilson at 09 Jan 2007 14:12
In agreement
From the Reverend Marcus SchultzWhilst I may deplore (mildly) the language your correspondent Ian Black is said to have used in writing to you, I must tell you that I agree with his sentiments wholeheartedly.
Marc Schultz at 09 Jan 2007 14:41
Commiserations
I feel sorry for you Mr Harnden - you must feel awful to read these messages of condemnation.But remember this - you brought their ridicule down on your own head, not just by lying in print, but by then boasting about it on today's blog.Let that be a lesson to you.
Martin at 09 Jan 2007 15:01
Good Grief!
Dear Readers - get a grip,PLEASE! To listen to your comments, you would think Mr. Harnden caused an innocent man to be hanged!! Journalists, it appears are not allowed to make mistakes, much less to own up to them. The personal attacks on Mr. Harnden seem to be coming from some sort of a nasty readership that makes me wonder who these mean-spirited souls are. Accusing Mr. Harnden of being pompous? Projection, perhaps....?
Cynthia Stone at 09 Jan 2007 15:08
Back! Back!
I sense a braying mob here, rounding on Mr Harnden. As with any should mob, they should disperse and regain some grip on their reason and personal conduct.I saw the Saddam story online while in Iraq the morning after Saddam's execution and thought, 'Whoops!'. It was inaccurate and left TH with some egg on his face. There was a lot of other rubbish written, the result of frenzied speculation by Iraqi and international media.But before we all put the boot in, let's ask whether any of those contributors with any journalistic experience can genuinely say they never got caught out in print. I think not.The personal nature of Mr Black's attacks on TH suggest a sour, dour individual who should get out more.I have met Toby Harnden, seen him at work, reviewed his writing against what I have witnessed myself and read a large volume of his work from N. Ireland, Iraq and the US. I rate him very highly as a journalist and will continue to read his work with as much good faith as one should invest in any report.If you don't like his writing there's plenty more to read elsewhere.
Cyrus Williams at 09 Jan 2007 15:23
Nasty vindictive readers
This illustrates why reporters should not be required to do blogs. They are honest about the limits of their trade and this is what happens.
Chris Fielding at 09 Jan 2007 15:36
Grow Up Mr Black
So Mr Black and his team of cooperative cohorts clearly don't like Mr. Harnden...Roger that! Now can we please get back to some legitimate opinions, or is this just going to be a forum for Mr. Black to vent old naval rivalries?
Jamie at 09 Jan 2007 15:38
What exactly did he do wrong?!
This is a reporter who is feeding the beast, as reporters call their newspaper, and described events as they stood when he when he was writing.I don't think he had any need to apologize.The problem he had is the age-old one of deadlines. And now the new one of foul-mouthed embittered old soaks resentful of their lot in life being able to vent online.
Benjamin Ambrose at 09 Jan 2007 16:01
No need for blogs
I do tend to agree with Chris Fielding that, in the case of Mr Harnden certainly, the use of blogs has backfired very badly on him.Harnden's assignment is to investigate and report the news from the USA (accurately) and to spend less time airing his views in blogs such as the one which has caused him such embarrassmment today.
Carnation at 09 Jan 2007 16:03
The way one expresses oneself...
...Reveals ones true colours. Mr Black's use of the c-word says all I need to know about the man.
Ari W at 09 Jan 2007 16:11
Consider the source
The accusations here against Mr. Harnden, seem to be that he 'lied'! In fact I believe he made it clear that the article on Saddam's execution, was written before the fact. By admitting his error, was this "boasting"? These personal attacks on the journalist, are to me, lower, than Harnden's journalistic error.
M. Shannon at 09 Jan 2007 16:15
sad
so sad that Britons think this abuse is justified. I read Mr Harnden regularly and he is as honest and insightful as they come.
JIM SNYDER at 09 Jan 2007 16:18
"lying"
The word I most object to is "lying" - bandied around willy nilly these days. This is a person who is telling us how, for reasons outside his control, an article was not as good as he would have liked. That shows he is conscientious and I find it interesting to hear about how newspaper errors can come about.
Margaret Broadbent at 09 Jan 2007 16:26
Fair comment
Has Mr Benjamin Ambrose (if that is, indeed, his real name) ever spent an evening in the company of journalists at any watering hole where the species congregates? Foul-mouthed language and a tendency to violence as the witching hour approaches is par for the course as your older staff members will doubtless remember.To accuse any of the correspondents who have contributed to this current debate of bad language, bad taste or of being "embittered old soaks resentful of their lot in life" is, to put it mildly, rather stretching a point.Let us not forget that if Toby Harnden had kept his mouth firmly shut in the first place we'd have all forgotten that he filed a story full of more holes than the proverbial watering can.
Donna Krupa at 09 Jan 2007 16:27
Profanity!!
Regardless of what anyone thinks of Harnden, I find it indefensible to send emails using profanity as a way of relaying personal opinions about the media. Black's crass manner of expressing himself says it all, really.
Alex Rathbone at 09 Jan 2007 16:30
phew
Most of you should be reading "Lunatics Today" instead of the Telegraph. Have any of you read T.Harnden's book or his Spectator articles? He is one of the most prolific and clever correspondents on Fleet Street.
Farmer Ged at 09 Jan 2007 16:49
His point is proved!
The point is that in this electronic age this is the type of thing journalists now have to deal with. Toby is man enough to bring it out into the open and then the nutters go and prove the point he was originally making.
You vilifiers totally miss the point at 09 Jan 2007 17:06
Take them on!
Good to see a reporter engaging with critics and showing them up for what they are. An email like that is totally indefensible.
Jan Volk at 09 Jan 2007 17:20
Saddam
Can we please return to the subject of Saddam and whether he deserved the manner of his demise? Mr Harnden actually highlights here how bizarrely it turned out in relation to how we had been told it would be done.
John Taylor at 09 Jan 2007 17:27
Substance please!
Mr Taylor is right. Whenever there is a serious, thoughtful subject on a blog everyone ignores it. Yet then gangs of people rush to defend someone as potty mouthed and vicious as Mr Black, who made no contribution at all to the sum of human knowledge (or kindness).
Karen at 09 Jan 2007 17:43
Dishing the dirt
How refreshing to see readers taking the opportunity to let newsmen (and women) know what we think when they screw up on a story!!Some of you seem to blame Mr Black for this whole debacle, when it seems to me his initial correspondence with Harnden was, if I am not mistaken, of a private nature in the form of an e-mail. Perhaps as a "prank" the recipient decided to make this correspondence public on his weblog, with disastrous results for Mr Harnden.What's so special about journalists, anyway? We are daily exposed to their opinions and stories which, as we know all too well, are not always based upon truth.So good on ya, Ian Black, lay into the blighterand let's have a lot more of this kind of reaction to mealy-mouthed hacks like the Telegraph's man in Washington!!
Summer at 09 Jan 2007 19:46
Copying stopped at this point ( having got interested in posts on the Apple iPhone).
ed: the entire 84 comments, including those not shown here, as well as Toby Harnden's original piece ( produced belatedly as a comment) were posted by handyblogman on the Guardian's OrganGrinder blog. I had alerted this site earlier in the day to the fact that Toby Harnden's blog had been "pulled". They were grateful for the tip, and in their news update provided a link to this site, which set the hit counter whirring. In fact over 1000 hits were recorded in the subsequent 12 hour period, from midday to midnight, over 6 times the peacetime figure.
But I decided to enter the fray later, under a pseudonym ( Non-blown-away sceptic) chosen earlier that day. Odd name, you might think, but it was related to the title of another post on the subject of Apple's iPhone, entitled "iPhone blows even the sceptics away" (Catherine Elsworth).
Here are my four main contributions (there were some later minor ones too). The second one resulted in Tony Harnden finally releasing the text of his initial "preview" story, which for reasons best known to himself he had withheld at the beginning, making it difficult to judge whether or not Ian Black had a case.
First posting : Separate issues
Why can't we just accept there are three entirely separate issues here, each of which is important.
1. Toby Harnden's reporting of the Saddam execution in the past, instead of the future tense .
2. Ian Black's lying in wait for years for a fellow journalist to make a mistake before revealing himself as someone from Harnden's previous existence. An unpleasant individual, with unpleasant language, confirming many of our worst stereotypes of the journalist's craft/trade (once called a profession).
3. Harnden's extraordinary decision to use his blog in a quality paper to "out" someone who had the temerity to send an unflattering email.
Why could Harnden have not started his report with " In a few minutes, if all goes according to plan, and barring any last-minute reprieves, Saddam Hussein will step onto the gallows ..... Thus will end the life of one of the world's most notorious ..... Will he be allowed to decline the customary hood .... ?
My own belief, for what it's worth, is that neither individual comes out of this with credit, but for entirely different reasons.
But it's the first which is the crucial issue: the reporting an event as if it had already taken place, when it had not.
What has happened here has served simply to compound the initial error, bringing it to the attention of everyone, when previously only a small observant minority might have spotted it.
Was the previous generation of naval officers taught how to shoot themselves in the foot ?
ed. The Telegraph moderators deleted the final sentence !
Second posting: Clarification still needed
Deanna. I did read Toby's original blog, in which he refers to the original report that caused him such embarrasment, but to which he gives no copy or link, merely to say he never used the past tense.
Two points: why would Ian Black have been so scathing if it had simply been a case of the Telegraph's deadline being before the execution? Are executions in China always coordinated with newspapers' deadlines ?
Where's the sin in writing about a likely scenario, ahead of the actual event, as long as that's made clear ? Has Ian Black never been called upon to do that ? Does he perhaps live in an ideal world, out there in China ? If so, why does he need to use gutter language ?
Second point: if you go to the end of the later updated report that Toby does cite, there's a link to another report that reads like an earlier version, under the byline of Toby Harnden (Washington) and Graeme Baker
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml;jsessionid=AH2ITOROFYMQLQFIQMFSFGGAVCBQ0IV0?xml=/news/2006/12/30/wsaddam30.xml
Title: Saddam: the end
"Hussein was hanged early today for his crimes against humanity.
The former dictator of Iraq was led to the gallows in Baghdad's fortified Green Zone, which houses his former presidential palace, before being executed without ceremony in front of Iraqi and American officials...... "
Is this the report that the Man- with- the- Score- to- Settle read, replete with its past tenses ? Or is there, as Toby said, an even earlier one that avoids the past tense. If so, why doesn't Toby provide a link or copy, and enlighten us on why's he supposed to have egg on his face (apart from the incorrect reference to a hood) ?
Third posting : Clear winner, unsavoury contest
Where are the "inaccuracies", Ian Black ? Or do you use that word loosely to mean differences in detail from events which the writer was attempting to visualise ?
If you were "chortling for hours" over a fellow-journalist being compromised by the clock and time-zones - through no fault of his own - then it shows you up for what you are. You are a petty-minded individual, harbouring a long term grudge, unable to move on, unable to make your point eloquently.
But Toby Harnden was perhaps out of order in using his blog to hit back in the way he did, divulging the contents of a private email without permission. As it happens, I had one from him shortly before Christmas. There was a standard message at the end from the Telegraph's legal department, warning against unauthorised publication of its contents, which I naturally respected.
Match to Harnden, despite throwing away a game or two, and antagonising spectators with his tactics.
Fourth posting: When was the future tense abolished ?
Seriously, some of you folk, is this really the first time in your lives that you have encountered one of those " Here's how it's likely to happen stories" ?
Did you really fail to spot the future tenses ?Does every article in this genre of reporting that tries to visualise an event that clearly hasn't yet happened - a fact of life, born of the rigid newspaper deadline - need to carry a health warning ? Like: "Stop. Read on at your peril. Beware concealed future tenses. Because actual events, when they occur, may not correspond with every detail you see here."
Sorry about the sarcasm, but if anyone knows of a better way of dealing with those unable to grasp what is self-evident, do please let us know.
Some afterthoughts from this blogger:
Having followed the thread closely (and contributed under a pseudonym) it seems to me that it's all a storm in a teacup, and that whilst Harnden's handling of criticism has lacked finesse, his professional credentials as a reporter at the time of of Saddam Hussein's (then) imminent execution did not seriously depart from normal journalistic practice. To meet his deadlines, he had to visualise the likely sequence of events, based on precedent and intelligent guesswork. It's what has been called a preview report.
Posted by
sciencebod
at
9:54 pm
3
comments
Labels: Corante, Daily Telegraph, dreams and daemons, Guardian, Ian Black, OrganGrinder, pulled blog, Shane Richmond, Suw Charman, Toby Harnden, Toby Harnden blog
Thursday, December 14, 2006
What got the President upset ?

There was a post yesterday by Toby Harnden in Washington on his Telegraph blog. The title was “Bush slams rude British reporters”. The gist was that the President has finally lost patience with the refusal of some of the British press corps to stand when he enters the room – apparently the only contingent not to do so.
Here’s a link to a YouTube video of his allegedly getting irate with a question from Nick Robinson of the BBC
Well, watch it for yourself, although it's quite long.
(Click on the green link above , then be patient: it takes a few seconds for the video to get moving)
The pictures above are a couple of freeze-frames that I captured from the site.
Here's the latest of three comments that I've placed on Toby's blog. As you will see, I am profoundly sceptical about Bush's response, long and emotional though it was, being linked to discourtesy on the part of our Washington media scrum, deplorable though it is (in my view) that they remain seated.
Run that past me again
I have just watched a replay of Bush's answer to Nick Robinson of the BBC. Angry response ? That's not how I would have described it. An initially startled, gob-smacked, rabbit-in headlights response, maybe, and then an emotional, back-to-the-wall posture. But there was no obvious personal rancour, and certainly no reference, or even hint, of chagrin against those journalists who failed to stand up.Sorry, can't see what all the fuss is about (unless Toby *Harnden's report is coloured or influenced by what he might subsequently have heard from the White House Press Corps).
Colin Berry at 14 Dec 2006 10:42
* Apologies, by the way, for misspelling as "Tony". There's a lot of distracting (roof repair) activity going on around me as I write !
The two earlier posts in the thread were to point out (casting modesty to the winds) that it had been yours truly who had first raised the matter of our journalists' conduct at White House press briefings. That was back in August, when Alec Russell was the Telegraph's man in Washington.
He had posted on the subject of the 2008 Presidential elections. Feeling that some of the current jockeying and polemics might look somewhat irrelevant in 2 years time, I wrote the following:
Boring and boorish
I can't imagine that a London-based journalist for the Washington Post would be salivating at the prospect of a UK General Election that was two years away. Yet Alec Russell seems here to be in the throes of a bad case of the local Potomac fever. Meanwhile, back here on Planet Earth, attention is fixed on the tragic events in Lebanon. I could forgive Alec and his fellow band of UK journalists in Washington if there were some consistency in their fixation with wannabee US Presidents. The US President is, after all, a Head of State, a position comparable to the Queen, though far more powerful because it's not above politics. So why does the UK press contingent refuse to stand when the President enters the briefing room at the White House ? I know they don't stand for the PM at home, but Tony Blair, despite his posturing on the world stage, is merely the head of a Government, not Head of State, and is not elected directly. I'm sure Alec Russell would stand if the Queen entered the room. But what happened anyway to the old dictum, "When in Rome ....". It seems to me boorish and discourteous in the extreme for a few to remain seated, drawing attention to themselves, when everyone else is standing. Don't misunderstand me - this is not about abject submission to a superpower, it's about elementary courtesy and good manners. If you think I'm someone who kowtows to George W Bush or to the USA, then open a thread, Alec, on the so-called "special relationship", and prepare for a broadside, all guns blazing.
Colin Berry at 08 Aug 2006 08:31
So imagine my (pleasant) surprise when Alec took this subject as the topic for his very next blog. Here's what he wrote:
In answer to the criticism of one Colin Berry who asks why British journalists stay seated when President George W Bush enters a press conference, I have to say I share his irritation.
The White House press corps can be a touch too self-important and grand. But to stand up when the head of state enters a room is not to compromise your objectivity, it is merely good manners.
If Colin had looked carefully at the footage of the last Bush-Blair press coverage or indeed the Bush-al-Maliki press conference a few days earlier he would have seen The Daily Telegraph’s correspondent upstanding.
So is this something to do with working for a newspaper of a traditional hue? I don’t think so. At least it appears that the Number Ten press corps is divided on the issue and not down ideological lines.
The other day when the two amigos strode into the East Room more than half the British press corps stood, the rest shuffled in their seat and stared defiantly ahead.
So when Toby posted yesterday, I reminded him of the provenance of this topic. Here's what I said, and his immediate reply.
Been there, done it ....
This debate induces a strong sense of déjà vu. Remember Alec Russell, erstwhile Washington correspondent for the Telegraph, who used to blog here ? He posted back in August on the subject of that despicable British-bum-on-seat brigade.
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/foreign/alecrussell/august06/communistneocon.htm
How do I know ? Because I was the one who was first to give our discourteous fellow countrymen a ticking off: they more than anyone should know that the office of US President is more comparable to that of our monarch, as distinct from prime minister, and thus RISE TO THE OCCASION !
Colin Berry at 13 Dec 2006 17:10
Here's Toby Harnden's immediate reply:
Telegraph solidarity
Toby Harnden at 13 Dec 2006 18:02
Considering in retrospect that I came close to accusing Toby of plagiarism (which was certainly not my intention) then that's a very friendly and courteous reply. A worthy successor, wouldn't you say, to the breezy and congenial Alec Russell ?
Re Alec: one hopes fortune will soon smile upon him, if it has not done so already, given the shabby way that he, Colin Randall and others were treated by their bosses at Telegraph Head Office.
This post has to be somewhat "telegraphic" too, for reasons already mentioned.
Postcript added 15th Dec: received a friendly email yesterday from Toby Harnden. He concludes with the following welcome news re Alec Russell: "Alec is going to Johannesburg for the Financial Times so he has very much landed on his feet."
Posted by
sciencebod
at
2:13 pm
13
comments
Labels: Alec Russell, Colin Berry, Daily Telegraph blog, George W Bush, Nick Robinson, seated journalists, Toby Harnden, White House press conference

